Hey YouTube - Seriously, WTF??!!!

Share this video on

What's Hot

What's New

Top Grossing

Top of the Chart

Recommend

Fran Blanche : Soooo many comments! Let me condense the major threads you are posting: 1) A great many FranLab subscribers have not gotten notifications of my new videos for months. 2) Many subscribers have discovered they were automatically unsubbed by YouTube without their knowledge. 3) Mysteriously, THIS video is trending. 4) Channels that receive support from Patreon but not Google ads are being ghosted out of recommendations on YouTube. 5) My fellow content creators overwhelmingly suggest that monetization may now be a requirement for participation on the platform.

Random Button Pusher : Funny that the first time I've heard of your channel is when this video showed up tonight in my "recommended" feed. It is a mystery.

Cody'sLab : You know I haven't seen any of your videos in a while and I assumed you stopped posting, I know I subscribed, and yet I am currently staring at a big red subscribe button... so ether I didn't and thought I did or youtube has unsubscribed me.

quotidianlight : count me in the auto unsubbed masses. I'm really beginning to hate youtube lately.

JimsEquipmentShed : Pretty funny how when you call them out on it, the bots must collect that data as well. Because this is the first time I have ever seen your channel. Very informative by the way.

Drew Pickard : Haha this video showed up on my recommended videos. The really funny thing is your content is the type of stuff I watch

MikesCarInfo : My channel is monetized and I had a massive drop in suggested views starting abruptly on June 1st. First half of the year was looking like the best year ever... last half seems to be the worst ever. It seems to be the same time that YouTube rolled out channel memberships and merchandising to content creators. They might be squeezing channels to get them to offset their income with the memberships and merchandise.

J.R. Regenold : Big tech is a controlling, subversive, monster ... motivation is not providing a public forum, it's making money for Alphabet Inc. That's WTF

NPC #45301239 : I discovered this video from my recommendations list. Whatever that means for you I dunno.

Bucyrus Erie12 : Hi Fran, I know you get many many comments and can't possibly reply to them all, but I wanted to know your opinion on this. I too was auto unsubbed from you, I did not realize until this video that it had happened... Then, your video from 6 yrs ago comes up on suggested videos... I watched it, not knowing about the TG topic and you, then read the comments.. Many were from people who didn't realize it was 6 yrs old and thought it was new.. Although there were many nice comments left, I was looking for a reply from you....And there weren't any. This bothered me.. I would have thought (never a good idea as I'm an idiot) that you would have replied to someone saying "thanks for the sympathy, but that was yrs ago" or something..anything.. Then I had a thought that upset me, I don't know how videos are set-up for suggested play, but I had watched hours and hours of your video's in the past, and that TG video never came up before..I would think because it's not about electronics. Is it possible that video is being suggested by YT for a negative effect? I know that's a horrible thought, however there are still people who don't understand Transgenders, and frankly never will.. and with all this other odd YT crap going on, who the heck knows? It is of course possible that you didn't reply because it's still painful emotionally... If that's the case, I am sorry I mentioned anything at all.. I love your video's, and all the stuff your into, and of course your oddly funny personality..Keep up the great work, Tom

EEVblog : That sucks. Something is not definitely not right. As long as you keep producing consistent content and your subs keep watching and engaging as usual, Youtube growth should be at least roughly linear. You were doing better than that in terms of existing subscriber engagement, so something is very wrong. The subscriber drop is almost certainly correlated with the lack of suggested video placement, and likely a drop in search result ranking too. Suggested videos is a huge thing now, accounts for about 40% of my daily views. My graph is here: https://imgur.com/DkFbHit

Ancient Bastard : Youtube is now penalizing the small creators that they never really wanted to give voices to. They used any willing creator solely to gain a huge following in a short time period, in order to attract these bigger corporations that will place ads. They will create cookie cutter, uncreative content that won't offend anyone to ensure they get as many Ads as possible to make the most money possible. Creativity in content will suffer greatly, and discussion of any subject matter the communists/leftists do not agree with will be Terminated with extreme prejudice, and the creator Doxxed so their family and careers can be destroyed for Wrongthink.

Karie Kavka : Back again with a question... Is there any other platform like YouTube?

Roger Bailey : I have been unsubbed from you and not my doing, I have now subbed to you once again - I also noticed my own channel views have been dropping too :(

Vivian Tries : Hi Fran, just wanted you to know that I found your video because YT suggested it. Hope things turn around for your channel.

Fracture : I think you nailed it. You're not taking ad revenue, so Google isn't making money off you. No soup for you! I wonder if Facebook "pay to be seen" tactics are on the way?

Richard Smith : The problem is this: Youtube feels more obligated to ensure the happiness of the advertisers than their employees. Period. Advertisers pay youtube, youtube pays youtubers, therefore their priority is to ensure advertisers get the best treatment even if that means negatively effecting youtubers. I think it is self destructive behavior, but due to youtube having a monopoly on this platform, they can get away with it. There is a lawsuit pending regarding this. I believe it was started by ZombieGoBoom.

Pirate Labs : Youtube demonetized my videos about 8 months ago and will not pay me the ad revenue I had built up. I have written to them many times with no response at all. I have been making videos here for about 8 years or so but, not any more. If they really need that money they refuse to pay me then I guess that tells all of us something about their company. They already got the views and got paid but want to keep all of the money and, now that I am no longer monetized, I have no way to make more videos to get paid in the future. So, I am thinking of removing my 75 videos and maybe posting them elsewhere.

Roger Junior : *YOUTUBE* AKA *GOOGLE* PLEASE ANSWER *FRAN BLANCHE*

LockPickingLawyer : There’s some irony in this showing up in my recommended list. 🤷🏻‍♂️ Good luck working through it. 👍

GHFear : Your videos also NEVER pop up on my YouTube homepage/recommended. Even tho I frequently watch. BUT I get a ton of recommendations for "Machine Gun Kelly", "Will Smith"" and Eminem" even tho I have NO interest in them and never even seen their videos.

Ben Kool : Welcome to the wonderful world called getting screwed over by YouTube Fran..

The Shootin' Dutchman : my understanding from many many other YouTube channel providers is that you can simply call you too and ask questions about what's going on with your Channel, I'm wondering why you haven't done that?

qrpnxz : 14:46 YouTube communicating with its lifeblood? Fat chance. But it does raise awareness. Thanks for making this video. Hadn't seen anything from you in a while, then suddenly I got suggested to me a few videos from you that I'd already watched a while back and finally this video. Hmm....

Cassandra Reed : Lol since you complained they suggested you lol I seen you

EEVblog : I think you might have to re-monetise your channel to test this, as doubt Youtube are going to tell you, as they have almost zero track record on doing that.

Paul Falcon : First time coming up in my recommendations for some time

Mr. VOID-OUT : Sorry I don't know you beyond being shoe-horned into my feed. Here's my view, good luck with your channel.

tyler durden : The *only* reason I clicked on the Video because of the Title and the Thumbnail.. With the Innocent Look, and what looks to be a very humble and nice lady..combined with the anger and emotion of the title to the video.. Well.. I just thought this ought to be good 😂😂😂

xpusostomos : For what it's worth, this video was suggested to me and is the first video of yours I've seen. And I'm in Australia. There's probably nobody in YouTube who could answer your question like there is nobody who can answer how some old machine works. The algorithm has dozens of inputs and who knows what AI to process them. But if you stopped taking ad revenue, which you kinda suggest you have, that would be bad. That is after all how Google makes money.

Mr. E : You came up in my recommendations. I think you solved your issue.

Patrick Rooney : You have a new subscriber and look forward to your future videos!!!!

L Twig : You just showed up in my recommendations and I don't know why. I watch very much unrelated content. I will check you out and see whats up!

Tim DeVoe : You are an absolute pleasure to listen to. A technician's dreamboat & poster girl. {^_^} A+++++

Axel1617 : I never heard of this channel till this video showed up in my recommended video list..........

saemus hailstorm : this HAS been going on w/other channels as well -

cfpradio creations fred et pierre : thats not fair. i watch all ypur video, one by one , at the breakfast , each morning of my lire. i hope To do this for the next 30 years. keep on going. and thank you so much for what you are doing for all of us. regards. frederic

Arnold's Design : Fran, I had the same thing happen to my channel starting first part of June. My graphs had been slowly and steadily increasing over time with each video I posted. Then in June my views and revenue dropped by about 50%. I'm fine with youtube tweaking their system, but if they're going to make changes that impact the lives of creators this drastically, at the very least, they shouldn't make rule changes retroactive. Let the old videos that were doing well be grandfathered in. If my videos were good enough six months ago to deserve the revenue they were getting, why are they not worthy now? It tells me their not overly concerned about the creators. I have come to learn that I can not depend on a platform with volatility like this, so I'm expanding into other streams of revenue on the internet to hopefully ensure it doesn't happen again. My channel is slowly starting to come back up to where it was before, but I'm still down about 40%. Makes it not worth busting your rump to come up with quality content anymore.

zg32e9 : bla bla bla bla bla bla... why is this in my recm?

Geoff Stockton : I miss the days when YouTube was a level playing field but it seems pretty obvious that Google is playing with a stacked deck and loaded dice these days. I'm probably going to delete my channel.

Noble Nomad : Time to leave Youtube!!!

Revamped Outdoors : It seems like they are changing the algorithm or something, I've noticed it a bit as well. Oddly enough my videos perform better with about 4-5 days between posting. If I do daily I might get the views but I don't get any engagement (comments/subs/likes) I'm thinking it's because the video gets served to a different type of viewership. Maybe the videos end up in a different genre so I get the click, but the person couldn't care less about my kind of content. Not sure but the post everyday mentality doesn't get me anywhere so meh, just doing it for fun so whenever a project is done I post. Hopefully they start serving your videos more frequently! I heard about your channel through electroboom and then I saw this in suggested so I sub'd. Keep up the awesome content!

Noevilea : I`ve just found your channel in the list at the side of another video. I've subbed and enabled notifications and I`m from Australia. However don't count on it as I`ve recently been finding I have been getting unsubbed from a number of channels. Why ? I have no idea . Something is going on since the UN took control of the internet October 2016 and YT is cutting their own throat. Anyone that thinks it is a free internet has nothing but rocks in their head.

CyberEditing : I recommend contacting Rob at VidIQ & do a stats deep dive. Your viewers comments about monetization was accurate. YouTube benefits from monetized watchtime.....& one of the myriad algorithms has acted in the manner you suspected. BTW, do you actively promote your channel across other social media platforms, such as IG (Instagram)? Regards, Mike, CyberEditing

Sam'sTrains : There's no data for the monetisation argument, YouTube are careful not to share this - but you you just have to follow the money. If 'the algorithm' has a choice between serving up videos that make money and those that don't, of course it will always choose the former. This isn't nice, and possibly it isn't even fair, but YouTube is a business that's becoming increasingly economically oriented. However, I don't think most viewers have a problem sitting through the odd advertisement - especially if they understand that they're supporting you by doing so. Why not give it a try, and see if it makes a difference?

Bob Flavin : I just checked my subs and I find that they only come from the UK and Ireland. I get no new subscribers from the US. I am monetised but only when I watched this video did I look back at May and I can see the same drop off Fran. I've just scraped over 30k subs and now I see why the subs rise so slowly.

PhilsComputerLab : Hmm I had a quick look at your stats and see it differently. You had constant, small growth for a long time, then a huge growth. Likely some viral video. That's a double edged sword, as those subs won't stick around and eventually it will go back to the organic growth. This video also seems to have triggered growth, maybe someone shared it, hard to say.

Shufei : Google has become much more aggressive and “evil” in their campaign for total web dominance this year. Adsense and youtube monetization are part of a larger schema to mine all internet interactions from the DNS on down to chrome surveillance and control. If you crowdfund, it may be your best bet to eventually switch to Peertube or some other alternative. Eventually the algorithmic manipulations will become so subtle and Machiavellian, youtube will be unusable for intelligent viewers.

Peter Collin : Fran, You're not alone. I have made friends with some guys who make woodworking videos professionally. In the last year they have seen their engagement go way down, views per video, and so on. There is lots of chatter about the reasons why. It seems like the amount of available content grows exponentially, so you are competing with way more other videos, new and old, and it's only going to get worse. So things get better from the viewing end, but worse for the content providers.

Vulgar Phil : Best of luck and more power to you! New sub!